Books, Reviews

REVIEW | She’s a Boy by Joe Holliday

she's a boy

Review:

I feel weird reviewing this because it’s not a story, this is real and it’s an autobiography about Joe/Joella. Although listed as an LGBT+ book, this is not about trans or genderfluid/non-binary people. This does, however, cover a lot about the gender spectrum. Joe was born without fully formed organs and some were missing entirely, including his genitalia. He was described by doctors as “intersex”. He was then told being raised a girl might be easier for him as it would be easier to create “female” genitals rather than construct male genitals. Throughout the book is about Joe’s struggles to be accepted as a girl while feeling like a boy, and how he questions gender as a whole.

It starts off being quite offensive to anyone on the gender spectrum:

“It’s really only a matter of different clothes, isn’t it?” she said when mum and dad explained what they’d been told. “Joel is still the same baby, they’re just telling you that he should have been wearing pink instead of blue”

“I’ve always said he’s too pretty to be a boy anyhow”

“Once I was asleep she put all of my boy’s clothes into a bin bag and got out the pile of girls’ things”

“It registered with mum that it was very boyish of me to be so interested in cars”

Obviously, it was really hurtful and not fun at all to read these with largely took up the first half of the story. As Joe started to understand himself more and how he felt, he brought up much better points on gender that were much less hurtful and harmful and the discussion of gender was a much better one:

“It became apparent that very many babies – up to one in 1000, according to some researchers – is born with an “intersex” characteristic. People can be born with the internal workings of one sex and the external appearance of another or with the genitals of a man but the chromosomes of a woman.”

“It was quite usual for babies with male chromosomes to be assigned to the female sex and vice versa”

“The chromosome test, like everything else we look at, should not be treated in isolation. The notion of there being two distinct and separate genders is becoming very outdated thanks to today’s science so we really must treat these results as a small part of the entire picture”

“Gender is a spectrum with males that have a penis, testes and XY chromosomes at one end and females that have a clitoris, labia, womb and XX chromosomes at the other and all kinds of variations inbetween”

“I think my case proves that gender is far more than a matter of clothes or conditioning. I was raised a girl in every way but I was absolutely a boy”

Although I personally see some things wrong here, like labeling genitalia “female” and “male” and saying some things are female and some things are male, etc., I think the points made were great ones. The book overall just had a gradual discussion on what gender is, more so than his other conditions but he did touch a lot on how not having a naturally formed digestive system did get in the way of his life sometimes and things like that.

Writing Style

It was very blunt, matter of fact and casual. It was kind of like he was sitting down at the table and just talking about what had happened to him over a drink. Although there was some parts that felt like kind of long-winded, and there were things that were repeated and that was kind of annoying. For most of the story, though, the writing style felt very friendly.

Overall

I know this wasn’t too long, but again it’s kind of hard to write reviews on autobiographies and something so personal and it got so dark near the end too that I wouldn’t really want to add to the negative media Joe has been fed a large portion of his life. I think this is an interesting take on the gender spectrum. From what I know, there’s a lot that isn’t really…right with this, but I think it’s a good starting point. It’s super emotional. I think I gave this three stars, but I would still recommend it. It’s not what I expected but I don’t think I can really blame the author for that.

Until next time,
Lorna

Book Wishlist

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “REVIEW | She’s a Boy by Joe Holliday”

  1. I remember reading about a pair of twin boys. One of their circumcisions went wrong and the baby’s genitals were cut badly. The doctors told the parents the baby’s genitals would never function correctly and that it would be best to turn them into female genitals. So they raised one baby as a boy and one as a girl, and it was considered sort of a social/science experiment to see if you could raise a child as the opposite gender from what they were born. They actually made a Law and Order SVU episode about it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Really? Oh that’s quite interesting! I always maintain the belief that gender is what the person says their gender is more so than what a doctor said it is but it’s interesting to see experiments happening where people can see that you can’t change what gender you feel like! 😀 (and if that twin girl liked being a girl, maybe she would have been trans had she have brought up a boy)

      Like

      1. It turned out she didn’t like being a girl, and always felt something was wrong. It was exasperated by the fact that the psychologist involved with helping her be raised as a girl thought it was a good idea to have the two twin children simulate sex together during their sessions because he claimed “sex play” was important to having her grow up as a girl. Its really a weird case. The twin raised as a girl actually went back to living as a male once he found out. Sadly, he later killed himself. I think it shows that what is in your brain outweighs what your body says… if you have a male body but in your mind you are female, then truly you’re female. And vice versa.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s